Skip The Extended Warranty

9 November 2013


Recently, I bought a shiny new flat screen television for my mother at Best Buy (had to replace the old television as the screen was changing colours and it was over seven years old) and of course, as we were ringing in the transaction, the customer sales representative asked if we would like the extended warranty.

Although I knew that extended warranties are usually a money grab courtesy of the electronics company, I was still worried about "what if", since the salesperson made it sound like everyone really should purchase the extended warranty because it is such a good deal.

Extended warranties can add quite a bit of cost to your purchase. For example, for a three year extended warranty, it would cost an extra $99 on top of the purchase price.  This would mean that should anything happen to the television after the one year manufacturer warranty, Best Buy would technically cover the cost of any repairs needed if the television broke down after the first year and within the extended warranty time period.

Well, before you listen to the sales pitch of the over-eager possibly commission-hungry salesperson, consider the facts behind extended warranties. Well, are extended warranties a good idea?

Here are five reasons why you should skip the extended warranty and save your money.

1. Most of the money goes to profit

According to Gail Vaz Oxlaide, personal finance guru, about 80% to 88% of all money spent on extended warranties ends up as profit for the company. That means that less then 20% of all the money spent on extended warranties is actually spent on paying for claims for servicing or replacement of parts to the electronic product.  Basically, they are an easy money maker for the electronics company.  In addition, apparently Best Buy doesn't have a very good track record for their extended warranties and customer satisfaction.  Check out the consumer affairs complaint site on the extended warranties at Best Buy.

2. Repairs cost the same amount as the warranty

Consumer Reports states that usually repairs (especially for appliances) cost the same amount as the extended warranty.  Therefore, if you were thinking about claiming your repair, Consumer Reports recommends that you skip paying for the warranty and just pay for the repairs yourself.  Besides, you might forget that you bought a warranty, and incidentally end up paying for it twice.

3. You might forget that you have a warranty

Let's face it; you probably had good intentions when you bought that extended warranty.  However, now that your television is acting funny, you're not sure where you put the extended warranty and on top of that, you're not sure if you are covered.  Life happens.  We misplace documents, we forget whether we are covered or even worse, we are too lazy to follow up and to see if the damage is covered under warranty.

4. Electronics Deflation

Even though food, gasoline, and life continues to get expensive, one of the only things that doesn't continue to appreciate in value is electronics.  Typically, electronics depreciate in value.  The $1000 you spent on that 50" flat screen Sony television will probably cost a few hundred dollars less in a few years.  The cost of the warranty can be less than the cost of a replacement in certain cases.  Yahoo Finance gives an example of a Blu Ray Player.  They were expensive when they came out, but are relatively cheap now.  It would most likely be more cost effective to buy a new player rather than fix one (though of course worse off for the environment).

5. Credit Cards are your friend (in some cases)

Although credit cards are not so great most of the time, many credit cards offer extended warranty protection beyond the regular manufacturer's warranty.  Just check with your credit card provider to ensure that your credit card covers any extended warranty past the manufacturer's warranty.

As mentioned, it might not be a good idea to buy the extended warranty (especially if you want to save money).  If you do buy the extended warranty, make sure that it will cover the repairs and parts that you are interested in.  Read the fine print and don't just take the salesperson's word for it.  They are taught to pressure you to spend money, but take your time.

Bargainmoosers, have you bought an extended warranty that was worth it?

(banner image credit: trenttsd)


  • Lenny Z.
    I do recommend getting an extra warranty for an Apple product...I needed it for my Mac and boy did it ever save me hundred of dollars on repairs by having it.
  • Luet02
    I have to agree about getting the extra warranty for an iPad. Mine stopped charging after a year, but thankfully it was fixed because of the extended warranty I purchased.
  • Theresa
    I have to recommend the Costco warranty for their computers. The extended warranty is varied depending if your computer is under $500 ($69) over $500 ($99). The best thing is if you do purchase you are already getting a 2 year warranty for free, then the ext. warr. covers a 3rd year. covers drops and spills, AND cracked screens. The TV Warranty is also great too because you get 5 years for under $100. 2 years free then 3 more years for no more than $100 depending on the size.
  • Tricia
    My husband worked in an electronics store formany years and the ext warranty can be pure profit. HOWEVER, I have to say that we got the extended warranty on our car and our home appliances. Turned out to be a godsend in both cases. 1. washing machine - they sent a rep out about 3 times and eventually decided that the cost to fix it would cost more than the unit so we got a cool $1200 to go get a new washer. 2. The car - wouldn't start when the engine was warm so we'd get stuck in parking lots and driveways all over the city. We were never charged for all the time they spent troubleshooting and fixing it. And, we were not given notice of a recall (confirmed by their own computer system), a bolt in loosened and was sucked into some hidden recess of the engine. They replaced the entire engine, no charge. This was towards the end of the extended warranty and thank goodness for it.

What do you think?

Your comment